Family and friendship are at the core of Brooklyn Tough, Lawrence S. Freundlich’s poignant collection of short stories. Against the colorful backdrop of Brooklyn, the novel is a sincere tribute to an earlier day an age when neighborhood devotion could be everything, even against the law and moral ambiguity. Freundlich spins an unforgettable tapestry of two men, their neighborhoods, their families, and the invisible code of honor that holds them all together.
At the heart of this mosaic are Johnny Catalfo and Asher Goldfine. They are not just friends; they are foils, mirrors, and emotional lifelines to each other. Their dialogue tinged with sarcasm, love, and shared history takes the reader through the book’s several plots and themes. Theirs is a friendship forged by decades of mutual experience, where old wounds, childhood memories, and moral compromises reside in the same breath.
Freundlich does not depict friendship as an unchanging bond. Rather, it develops throughout stories from slapstick patter at Monty’s restaurant to earnest discussions of religion and children. In one, Johnny goes to a Seder at Asher’s house and exchanges Talmudic patter shot through with criminal suggestion. In another, the two ponder what their sons will be while strolling on the Brooklyn Promenade. Each vignette contributes to a rich description of masculine intimacy, constructed not only on love but on survival and hard-won mutual support.
Maybe more critical is the depiction of family. Whether Angela, Asher’s wife, or Anunciata, the legendary matriarch, Freundlich’s women are not background players. They shape decisions, nurse grudges, and provide the emotional backbone of the Goldfine-Catalfo extended family. In one of the most vivid stories, Anunciata orchestrates a clandestine mission to get smoked salmon at Russ & Daughters not for her own purposes, but to mark her grandson’s homecoming from Oxford. It’s a very traditional, loving, and culturally proud gesture.
Freundlich is a virtuoso at blending the sacred and the profane. In the same sentence, he may deflect from a description of Mafia logistics to a meditation on the love of a father for his son. This dichotomy is the essence of Brooklyn: tough on the outside but fiercely loyal to its own.
This is not by accident. Freundlich is a Brooklyn kid who, after decades in the Manhattan publishing establishment, came back not only physically but in spirit as well. His tales are populated with landmarks that feel lived-in Court Street delis, the Promenade in Brooklyn Heights, and bustling Jewish delis. There is no romance here. There is instead reverence a respect for the lives, the flaws, and the victories of ordinary folk.
The book is also an act of personal transformation on Freundlich’s part. His transformation from a high-strung editor into a recovering drunk who writes makes him an emotional peer to his characters. Like Goldfine and Catalfo, he has lived through loss, ego, failure, and redemption. His emotional authenticity as a writer comes from experience, not from invented drama.
Maybe the highest praise Brooklyn Tough provides is to community itself. In an era of loneliness and individualism, Freundlich reminds us of the invaluable nature of connection. His characters fight, betray, and use one another but they also care for, guard, and forgive. It is in these contradictions that the spirit of Brooklyn glows most brightly.
Friendship and family, in Freundlich’s universe, are not idealized. They are worked through, complicated, and frequently inconvenient. But they last. And that, above all, is what lends Brooklyn Tough its pulsing heart.





Leave a comment